Most Players of the Year - Delphos St. John’s, 12
Most Offensive Players of the Year - Delphos St. John’s, 8
Most Defensive Players of the Year - Marion Local, 5
Offensive Player of the Year Breakdown – 12 QB’s, 10 RB’s, 1 WR
Defensive Player of the Year Breakdown - 16 LBs, 3 Interior Linemen, 3 Defensive Backs, 2 Defensive End’s
Two-Time Players of the Year – Chad Schulte, Delphos Delphos St. John’s (1997-98); Zach Weber, Delphos Delphos St. John’s (1999-2000); Kevin Hoyng, Coldwater (2001-02); Ross Homan, Coldwater (2004-05); Jordan Thompson, Parkway (2006-2007), Chris Pohlman, Delphos St. John’s (2009-10)
| Year | Offense | Defense |
| 2011 | Jake Heitkamp, RB – Marion Local | Daniel Gusching, LB – Minster |
| 2010 | Jordan Leininger, QB – Delphos St. John’s | Chris Pohlman, LB – Delphos St. John’s |
| Reese Klenke, WR – Coldwater | Cody Bensman, DE – Anna | |
| 2009 | Wes Ulm, QB – Delphos St. John’s | Chris Pohlman, LB – Delphos St. John’s |
| 2008 | Tony Harlamert, RB – Coldwater | Adam Homan, LB – Coldwater |
| 2007 | Chris Stucke, QB – Marion Local | Jordan Thompson, LB – Parkway |
| 2006 | Andy Puthoff, RB – St. Henry | Jordan Thompson, LB – Parkway |
| 2005 | Steve Borger, QB – Coldwater | Ross Homan, LB – Coldwater |
| 2004 | Nate Stahl, QB – St. Henry | Ross Homan, LB – Coldwater |
| 2003 | Ben Shappie, RB – Versailles | Ryan McNeilan, LB – Versailles |
| 2002 | Kevin Hoyng, QB – Coldwater | Mick Bollenbacher, DE – Marion Local |
| 2001 | Kevin Hoyng, QB – Coldwater | Keith Recker, LB – Delphos St. John’s |
| 2000 | Zach Weber, RB – Delphos St. John’s | Lucas Bowen, LB – Parkway |
| 1999 | Zach Weber, RB – Delphos St. John’s | Doug Martz, LB – Delphos St. John’s |
| 1998 | Chad Schulte, RB – Delphos St. John’s | Keith Walls, DB – Coldwater |
| 1997 | Chad Schulte, RB – Delphos St. John’s | Ben Schmiesing, LB – New Bremen |
| 1996 | Ryan Uhlenhake, QB – St. Henry | Nick Moeller, LB – Marion Local |
| 1995 | Shane Franzer, QB – Coldwater | Kraig Dippold, Interior Line – Marion Local |
| P.J. Seiter, DB – Minster | ||
| 1994 | Ken Keirns, RB – Delphos St. John’s | Chris Huelsman, Interior Line – St. Henry |
| 1993 | Doug Speck, RB – St. Henry | Mark Thobe, LB – Marion Local |
| 1992 | Tom Hoying, QB – St. Henry | Steve Prenger, Defensive Back – Minster |
| 1991 | Scott Elwer, QB – Delphos St. John’s | Chris Clune, LB – Marion Local |
| 1990 | Bob Hoying, QB – St. Henry | Jeff Hartings, Interior Line – St. Henry |
Special thanks to Robb Hemmelgarn for sending this in for use by MidwestAthleticConference.com